Hey everyone, I’ve been working on a new keyboard switch concept that uses compressed air instead of metal contacts or magnets. Based on Boyle’s Law, it offers a unique “floating” bottom-out feel with physically adjustable resistance via a micro bleed valve.
Neat idea, love that you actually tested it with a syringe first.
Couple worries though: I don’t think the valve actually changes how hard the switch feels mid-press, just how fast it springs back after, the air resistance itself comes from geometry, not the valve. Also worried about the seals getting sticky over time, and if a seal ever leaks, the key just won’t return at all (way worse than a normal switch wearing out).
Cool concept though, curious to see where you take it!
Thank you for your feedback, Aksara! I really appreciate you taking the time to read through my proposal.
You’re absolutely right about the valve - it primarily affects the return speed rather than the downstroke feel. I designed it that way intentionally: the valve gives users control over the reset speed, while the downstroke hardness is determined by the chamber geometry (cross-section area, stroke length, etc.). It’s a trade-off, but I think it provides a unique “adjustable release” experience.
As for the seal concerns - yes, that’s the biggest engineering challenge. Currently considering FKM rubber for its oil/heat resistance, and I plan to make the seal replaceable so users can swap it out if it degrades. It’s a maintenance issue, not a fundamental flaw.
Thanks again for the kind words and thoughtful questions. I’ll keep updating the proposal!